The New York Times raised eyebrows recently with a report about the rise of a questionable practice in journalism called quote approval.
Reporters seeking to cover President Barack Obama and challenger Mitt Romney have frequently been offered interviews only after agreeing to submit quotes to the campaigns for approval before printing them. With this stipulation -- dubbed "revise and consent" by Carl Sessions Stepp of American Journalism Review -- the campaigns can rigidly adhere to their message despite occasional slips of the tongue.
"Jim Messina, the Obama campaign manager, can be foul-mouthed," the Times' Jeremy Peters wrote. "But readers would not know it because he deletes the curse words before approving the quotes. … Stuart Stevens, the senior Romney strategist, is fond of disparaging political opponents by quoting authors like Walt Whitman and referring to historical figures like H.R. Haldeman, Richard Nixon's chief of staff. But such clever lines rarely make it past Mr. Stevens."
For journalists to be complicit in sanitizing their sources' statements is ethically dubious. But with media outlets such as Bloomberg News, The Washington Post, Reuters and the New York Times agreeing to quote approval, a "go along to get along" attitude is often the only way to gain access to those who make the news.
"We don't like the practice," New York Times Managing Editor Dean Baquet said. "We encourage our reporters to push back. Unfortunately, this practice is becoming increasingly common, and maybe we have to push back harder."
The Associated Press, to its credit, has taken a firm stance against the practice. (The same goes for The Daily Star.)
"We don't permit quote approval. We have declined interviews that have come with this contingency." AP bureau chief Sally Buzbee said to the Poynter Institute.
Quote approval can be useful for stories involving, for example, scientists who use esoteric technical jargon. But, as former Bush administration press secretary Ari Fleischer said in a CNN op-ed this week, such is not the case for the vast majority of sources who demand quote approval.
"Pushback has now turned into quote approval for everyone, even when the story isn't nuanced or complicated," Fleischer wrote. "Reporters are easily acquiescing to midlevel aides who seek quote approval. … As a former press secretary, I'm all for trying to control the press, but quote approval goes too far."
The relationship between reporters and sources will always be part-collegial, part-adversarial. But this give-and-take crosses the line when coddling sources is raised to greater importance than providing readers with honest coverage.
Opinion
'Quote approval' crosses an ethical line
- Opinion
-
-
On our Opinion: Cheers
To the DEP's "The Watershed Experience," the Oneonta High School Envirothon team, and to ROPS rebate funding.
-
Make sure Blodgett project holds water
Many thanks to Dennis Finn and the Planning Commission for allowing unrestricted public comment on the Blodgett Drive housing project at the commission’s May 15 meeting. Most who spoke are residents of the area who know the safety and drainage issues well.
-
We need a law against Google Glass
It’s a technological marvel; a product ahead of its time, or at least ahead of the law for the time being, that is.
-
Make sure you vote in school tax election
School superintendents have it anything but easy in these challenging economic times. In addition to dealing with myriad day-to-day and semester-to-semester issues, they have to have Solomon-like political acumen and management skills.
-
No foreign aid until our needs are met
I couldn't agree more with Sal Furnari's letter published in the Weekend edition. I would also like to add that when I was growing up I was taught to "take care of my own first" and then share with others.
-
THIS WEEK'S POLL
-
It's sad to see Rich Murphy retire
It was a sad day for Otsego County when Rich Murphy announced his intention to retire from the county board at the end of his current term.
-
Liberal media only care about themselves
Sounds like it all depends on 'whose ox is being gored' when it comes to the illegal phone tappings of reporters.
-
Street Talk: May 20, 2013
Do you think that recent high school graduates have a harder time finding a job than previous generations?
- Saturday, May 18, 2013
-
Casino in our area worth talking about
If Gov. Andrew Cuomo has his way, casinos will be awarded to three upstate locations.
-
Public financing could cure pols' paranoia
Paranoia is an irrational fear of persons, places or events that have no basis in reality.
-
Resort proposal is just too big
Belleayre Mountain Ski Center is a New York state taxpayer-owned recreational area. People who have paid for BMSC with their hard-earned dollars should not have to also pay for the infrastructure necessary to assure an enjoyable ski experience for the visitors to a private developer's monster mega-mall/spa resort on a mountaintop.
- Friday, May 17, 2013
-
Take precautions to prevent kidnappings
It has been nearly two weeks since the arrest of Ariel Castro in Cleveland on rape and kidnapping charges for acts that should send a chill through the spines of everyone in America.
-
Redistributing wealth just isn't fair
Yesterday a dozen of us were eating lunch in the break room where I work, most of us complaining that all we could afford was peanut butter and jelly and bologna ... except for Rob.
-
Hoping many will adopt a grave
It's that time of year again; adopt a grave. I am hoping when you buy flowers or a plant for a family member or friend's grave that you will buy some for another grave. I wish everyone would open up their heart and honor someone else by putting flowers on their grave. My hope is that groups, families and youth groups adopt a cemetery or a grave, and at least once a year that person or persons will be remembered. I started out with two and now am up to 14. It doesn't have to be expensive; just what your heart tells you to do.
- Thursday, May 16, 2013
-
IRS, Justice actions violate our trust
After the recent actions of the Internal Revenue Service and the U.S. Justice Department, belief in the integrity of our government is hanging by a very slender thread.
-
Blame Dems for Social Security woes
In his inaugural address President Kennedy said: "Ask not what your country can do for you, ask what you can do for your country.'
- Wednesday, May 15, 2013
-
After 40 years, it was time to get married
This newspaper publishes lots of wedding announcements, but one that appeared prominently in Monday's edition was especially heartwarming.
-
Newman housing would benefit city
I would like to comment on the excellent letter written recently by Alan Cleinman concerning the "Newman Development."
-
Paying what you can afford won't work
Our president said:
-
On our Opinion: Cheers
