The Daily Star, Oneonta, NY - otsego county news, delaware county news, oneonta news, oneonta sports

Mark Simonson

December 19, 2011

Readers keep me on my toes with facts and figures

I start this entry feeling just a tiny bit smarter by being a former elementary school student at Center Street School. By the time you finish reading this, I'll feel back to normal as I quickly approach the completion of my 13th year of writing about local history.

As I've been writing columns, I'm always happy to get feedback from readers. Some send me surprises about things I may not have been aware of or overlooked while doing research. Then there are the times I just slip up.

A few months ago, I wrote about Oneonta native Sherman Fairchild, a famous inventor and industrialist, who got his first break with a special camera he invented in 1920. In that article, I'd mentioned Fairchild began his education in Oneonta's schools, but I didn't know or mention which one.

Not long after, Mark Parmeter, librarian at Center Street School, sent a class photo from the earlier years at the school, showing Sherman Fairchild shortly after the turn of the 20th century. I enjoyed the thought that my classmates and I once walked those same hallways as Fairchild. He eventually went into private schooling, both here and in Arizona.

Also on the topic of cameras, I'd written an article about the early photography of Horace and Ralph Hanford, capturing the early years of people and progress in the hamlet of East Meredith. After the two had stopped taking photos from glass plates and film, their work was tucked away for many years.

Neither Hanford Mills Museum nor I had told the whole story of how the Hanford photo collection had arrived at today's museum. Grace Kent, a longtime neighbor of the museum, pointed out that the bulk of the Horace Hanford Collection came to the museum in 1976 as a donation by Ralph Hanford, Horace's son. The donation included 105 dry plate glass negatives. At a different date, Ronald and Grace Kent, who had purchased Horace's old house, discovered a box in the attic that contained 65 additional glass plate negatives, five flexible negatives, and 191 roll film negatives. The Kents donated this trove to the museum, and it was determined that the 65 glass negatives were the work of Horace Hanford. The roll negatives were by Horace's son, Ralph, and were thus grouped into a new category called the Ralph Hanford Collection.

A few months ago, I had written about "Frank Malzone Day" in Oneonta, back in October 1957. Malzone got his start as a member of the 1949 Oneonta Red Sox team and went on to the big club in Boston. Malzone remained fond of Oneonta, because he married Amy Gennarino and came back often to visit the in-laws.

While I captured the mutual admiration between Malzone and Oneonta's citizens, alas, being a baseball story, a few readers pointed out I committed a few errors, involving some player statistics.

I must have been in a hurry in research and writing, as in my notes I had written down DH. Frank's first games with Boston in 1955 were in a double header in September, being called up from the Minor Leagues. I said he was a designated hitter. That "DH" in my notes was my error. There was no designated hitter in baseball until 1973, adopted by the American League.

I had also mentioned that Malzone got six hits in a row during that double header. I had misinterpreted a Saturday Evening Post article from 1958 about Malzone's triumph over personal tragedy. Malzone got six hits on the day, but according to Retrosheet.org, Malzone got four hits in the first game and two in the second.

The magazine article was amusing, describing how, after the double-header, Frank called Amy back in Oneonta, so excited he could hardly talk.

"What are you trying to tell me?" she finally asked.

"Six_six_six," he sputtered. "I got six hits today!" "And I got left $6 million by a long-lost uncle," she retorted.

"Amy says now, 'It took him five expensive minutes to convince me he wasn't kidding. And even though we couldn't afford to talk that long, I didn't begrudge him a minute," read the Saturday Evening Post.

Finally, to clear up a few more errors, I had said the Agro Farma plant, maker of Chobani yogurt, was located in the town of New Berlin, while it is in the town of Columbus. I had also given a wrong title to Nancy Bromley of Greene, in a Civil War letters entry. Bromley is the president of the Greene Historical Society, not the Greene town historian. The latter is Peg Ross.

Hopefully I'll be back in my Fairchild moments soon.

This weekend: Oneonta celebrates Christmas in wartime, 1941.

City Historian Mark Simonson's column appears twice weekly. On Saturdays, his column focuses on the area during the Depression and before. His Monday columns address local history after the Depression. Write to him at The Daily Star, or e-mail him at simmark@stny.rr.com. His website is www.oneontahistorian.com. His columns can be found at www.thedailystar.com/marksimonson.

Text Only
Mark Simonson

Additional Content
Join the Debate
Helium
Additional Resources
CNHI News Service
Poll

Should high schoolers play football despite the risk of concussions.

Yes
No
     View Results