The Daily Star, Oneonta, NY - otsego county news, delaware county news, oneonta news, oneonta sports

Local Sports

July 3, 2009

After you catch it, let the big one get away

The quest for a huge brook trout has led fisherman into the wilderness for many, many years.

Sure you can fly to Labrador in northeast Canada and catch brookies upwards of 10 pounds, but that's an expensive proposition.

To me, searching that back-country pond in the beautiful Adirondacks and hoping to find a three- to five-pounder is the ultimate challenge.

Years ago, big brook trout were common, but with acid rain and over-fishing, those big, brightly colored, trophy fish are few and far between these days.

In the Adirondack Explorer _ a bi-monthly publication _ there is a regular section called "Questions for Clarence." Clarence Petty is a 103-year resident of the Adirondacks. In each issue, he answers a bunch of questions about his beloved mountains.

The March/April issue asked, "What's your favorite wild area in the Park?"

Petty replied: "I like the Cold River country. My brother and I would go there in the spring and catch five- to seven-pound brook trout in the river, in the rapids there. It was so shallow that their fins would stick out of the water. They're gone now."

The last time I hiked along the Cold River, I didn't catch a fish. Places such as Miller's Falls and Big Eddy should have held some great brookies, but not any more.

Word has traveled around the fishing community about catching five pounders in the St. Regis Wilderness Canoe Area, and in 2006, the state record fell in some unidentified, back-country pond north of Old Forge.

Places that hold big trout usually remain a secret. That big brookie weighed 4 pounds, 11 ounces.

On June 7, Tom Yacovella of Utica was fishing on Raquette Lake in northern Hamilton County when he got a hit on his Rapala lure. He landed a state record for brook trout, at 21 inches long and 5 pounds, 4.5 ounces.

It's interesting that Raquette Lake is a well-populated area right in the village. You don't have to hike back into the mountains, carrying your canoe and fighting the bugs. It's accessible right from the highway.

Yet right there in civilization, a huge brook trout lived for many years. How many fishermen have trolled that same water and never thought a giant brookie still lived there?

I'm not going to rush north and fight the crowds for a chance to land another big trout among the dozens of other boaters on the lake. To me, the brook trout is a symbol of the wilderness _ and that's where I want to find them.

I once asked an old Adirondack guide where I might find some good brookies. "Johnson Vly," he replied. And so, I ventured off.

The climb was steep as I struggled to the top of the mountain. I should have known better when I followed the well-beaten path, but that was when I was new to the mountains. Everyone else had fished that little pond. I was 30 years too late.

What do they say? "Records are meant to be broken."

Some place in the wilderness, another big fish will be caught.

I just hope they'll take pictures and then turn him back into the deep, cold water of that secret, secluded pond.

That's where he belongs.

Rick Brockway writes a weekly outdoors column for The Daily Star. E-mail him at robrockway@hotmail.com.

Text Only
Local Sports
  • Pats win fourth straight East title

    HIGH SCHOOL BOYS BASKETBALL ROUNDUP ... Kyle Jaquay and Isiah Montgomery had 18 points each as Cherry Valley-Springfield's boys basketball team won its fourth straight Tri-Valley East Division title with a 68-38 road win over Worcester on Wednesday.

  • Oneonta High girls cruise to road victory

    HIGH SCHOOL ROUNDUP ... Natalie Vanderlaan-Meyering had 10 points, 11 rebounds and eight blocks to lead Oneonta High's girls to a 51-34 Southern Tier Athletic Conference basketball victory at Chenango Valley on Wednesday.

  • Hartwick men ranked first in East Region

    COLLEGE ROUNDUP ... Hartwick College's men are the top-ranked team in the initial East Region basketball poll that was released Wednesday.

  • Today's Datebook

  • OHS boys fall in 4 OTs

    HIGH SCHOOL BOYS BASKETBALL ROUNDUP ... Zach Collins scored eight of his game-high 30 points in the fourth overtime and Chenango Valley beat host Oneonta High, 92-88, in a Southern Tier Athletic Conference boys basketball game Tuesday.

    1 Photo
  • Hartwick women extend streak to 10

    COLLEGE ROUNDUP ... Hartwick College scored 16 of the last 20 points to beat host Albany College of Pharmacy, 62-46, in a non-conference women's basketball game Tuesday.

  • Boys basketball state rankings

  • Worcester clinches East title

    HIGH SCHOOL GIRLS BASKETBALL ROUNDUP ... Morgan Clark, Karli Pochkar and Cassie Sklenka scored six points apiece as Worcester opened a 12-point halftime lead in its Tri-Valley League East Division-clinching, 38-24 girls basketball victory at Cherry Valley-Springfield on Tuesday.

  • Today's Datebook

  • Area Sports Briefs

  • Tuesday, February 7, 2012
  • OHS girls clinch division

    HIGH SCHOOL GIRLS BASKETBALL ... ONEONTA _ Kelsey Baker hears voices in her head, but only when she's at the foul line. "I hear everyone in the background and stuff," Oneonta High junior forward Baker said Monday night, "but mainly, it's just me, the ball and the basket. You've just got to make them." Junior forward Baker made five clutch free throws in a row in the fourth quarter, when she scored seven of her team-high 11 points to lead host Oneonta High to a 35-27 girls basketball victory over Norwich.

  • Edmeston boys hold off RS

    HIGH SCHOOL ROUNDUP ... Brandon Fallon capped his 14-point night on a layup with about 40 seconds left that provided the winning points in Edmeston's 54-52 Tri-Valley League boys basketball victory at Richfield Springs on Monday.

  • O-State coach, Unatego AD takes job in Fla.

    The recent departure of Bill May left vacancies at Oneonta State and the Unatego School District. May, 47, was announced as Southeastern University's women's tennis coach Friday. He'll also be the school's men's tennis coach the following season when that program begins its first season. May spent seven seasons as the men's and women's tennis coach at Oneonta State. He served as athletic director at Unatego the last two seasons.

  • College Roundup

  • YOU SAID IT!

  • Area Sports Briefs

  • Delaware League Standings

  • Girls Basketball State Rankings (as of Feb. 5)

  • Today's Datebook

  • Monday, February 6, 2012
  • B-G/A wrestlers edged in Class B; Unatego second in C

    HIGH SCHOOL WRESTLING _ CLASS CHAMPIONSHIPS ... Bainbridge-Guilford/Afton fell just short of successfully defending its Section Four Class B wrestling championship as Windsor beat the Bears by one point in the 10-team tournament Saturday at Waverly.

    2 Photos

Additional Content
Join the Debate
Helium
Additional Resources
CNHI News Service
Poll

Do you think we will have a big snow storm the rest of the winter?

Yes
No
     View Results