COOPERSTOWN -- As tourists clog Main Street on the week leading up to National Baseball Hall of Fame induction ceremonies, one of the businesses catering to them is waging a counteroffensive against a village committee's decision to stop it from making changes to its outdoor patio restaurant and bar.
All-American Cafe, at 99 Main St., filed legal papers in state Supreme Court this week, arguing that the village Historic Preservation and Architectural Review Board improperly denied it a "certificate of appropriateness" for what the eatery's management said are "temporary" improvements.
The court papers state the improvements in question include a new bar with a stainless steel top, additional trellis work to shield the working area of the kitchen from patrons and new decorations and lighting to "enhance the dining experience."
According to the lawsuit, the cafe's management believed the "augmentations" were not alterations of the property because they were not permanently affixed to the building at the location and are going to be removed at the conclusion of the summer tourism season.
On May 17, the village zoning enforcement officer, Tavis Austin, cited the cafe with a stop-work order because the management had failed to obtain the certificate of appropriateness, the lawsuit stated.
On June 12, Richard Busse, the president of Pioneer Patio Restaurant Inc., the company that owns the restaurant, urged the preservation board to issue the certificate, noting it had issued a certificate for a new awning in February and he was not aware he needed a second certificate for the augmentations.
The board, by a 3-2 vote, rejected Busse's request. Those denying the request were the board's chairwoman, Teresa Drerup, and members Roger MacMillan and Wendell Tripp.
The lawsuit, known as an Article 78, contends that the decision was "arbitrary and capricious and an abuse of discretion in that the determination of incompatibility of the improvements appears to be based solely on the fact that one of the improvements included a 'bar' rather than another table for patrons."
Subsequent to the action of the preservation board, the village trustees authorized village attorney Martin Tillapaugh to enforce Austin's stop-work order, according to the legal papers.
Tillapaugh, contacted by The Daily Star, said the objective of the village is not to shut down the cafe but to get it to stop using the steel bar, a mounted television screen and the new lattice.
He said the preservation board simply decided that Busse "can't construct something that is not historically appropriate."
According to the court papers, the All-American Cafe is a tenant of American Baseball Experience Inc., whose president is local businessman Perry Ferrara.
The papers state the outdoor bistro has been operating at the location for the past seven years.
Local News
Cafe sues Cooperstown over denial of improvements
- Local News
-
-
Ramsaran freed on $300,000 bail
Accused killer Ganesh "Remy" Ramsaran was freed from Chenango County Jail this afternoon after he and relatives posted $300,000 worth of real estate to meet bail conditions set by County Judge Frank Revoir Jr.
-
Area school budgets get voters' OK
With schools in the area proposing budgets at or below the state tax cap, all districts reporting by 10 p.m. said voters approved their spending plans.
-
School budget voting results
-
Tree-killing insect found near Unadilla
A tiny pest with a big appetite for ash trees has arrived in Delaware and Otsego counties, according to the state Department of Environmental Conservation.
-
Roxbury artist's portrait exhibit is a record-breaker
ROXBURY -- Greg Frederick is an artist who has likely broken more records than anyone reading this story today. By records, we mean that relic of the musical recording industry -- vinyl long-playing albums (the ones with the small hole in the center) and 45 revs per minute single records (the ones with the considerably larger hole in the center).
-
Bruni to step down after 30 years
Children's programs, a computerized card catalog and online access to a world of information are among changes ushered in at the Huntington Memorial Library in Oneonta by Marie Bruni since she became library director 30 years ago. "It's been great,'' Bruni, who plans to retire, told the Oneonta Common Council during a meeting in City Hall on Tuesday night.
- Tuesday, May 21, 2013
-
State investigation seeks missing Bassett Rx pads
The state is investigating the possible theft of blank prescription pads from Bassett Medical Center, a spokeswoman for the hospital confirmed Monday.
-
Classes resume after threats at schools
School was opened on schedule at two area schools where Internet threats caused lockdowns Friday afternoon, two superintendents said Monday as the investigations continued.
-
Survey: Town residents cool to merger
More than half of Oneonta town residents responding to a survey oppose the idea of a merger with the city of Oneonta, the study summary said.
But a majority said "yes" to a partnership with the city to protect the reservoir and quality of drinking water. Two-thirds oppose drilling for natural gas, according to responses, the survey reported, and a majority supports commercial and industrial development in the town.
-
Lawmakers: Farm bill has 'devastating' mandates
-
Correction
-
Copes Corner Park gets new lease on life
The job description for town supervisor doesn't normally include mowing grass, but that's what Charlie Eckelmann found himself doing the other day over at Copes Corner Park in the hamlet of Gilbertsville.
-
School budget votes held today statewide|
Voters across the state go to the polls today to decide the fate of their local school budgets. In many cases, the selection of board of education candidates and propositions are on the ballot.
-
Blodgett plan review to continue at meeting
The Oneonta Planning Commission on Wednesday will continue its review of environmental impact documents submitted as part of a site plan application for a proposed student apartment complex on Blodgett Drive.
-
Area life coach wins state recognition
Heidi Friedman, a local life coach, has been awarded a statewide honor by The Arc, a 60-year-old national organization, and ANCOR, an associated organization.
- Monday, May 20, 2013
-
Fill each day, SUCO grads told
Two speakers at the State University College at Oneonta asked audiences to push the ``pause button'' on their lives Saturday.
-
Community comes together to build playground
The quote "If you build it, he will come" from the 1989 film "Field of Dreams" is often slightly altered to "If you build it, they will come."
-
Police to patrol schools after threats
Police will be present at public schools in Delhi and Walton today as a precaution in the aftermath of last week's online threats, school officials said Sunday.
-
Ramsaran remains in jail
Ganesh Ramsaran, accused of murdering his wife, remained in Chenango County jail Sunday on bail, authorities said.
-
Library, airport on council agenda
The Oneonta Common Council will consider the future of the Huntington Memorial Library and of the municipal airport, among other business, during a meeting Tuesday night.
-
Ramsaran freed on $300,000 bail
