The Daily Star, Oneonta, NY - otsego county news, delaware county news, oneonta news, oneonta sports

March 12, 2010

Letters to the Editor: March 12, 2010


Bill is a bailout for abortion industry

Neither alone, nor in the minority, I am insulted by President Obama’s brazen attack on the unborn as he tries to ram through a decidedly unpopular health care bill that provides government funding of abortion.

Poll after poll shows that Americans _ upwards of 72 percent _ are against the current bill, yet Congress is insistent, almost obsessed, on trying to pass health care reform laden with abortion activist initiatives, oblivious to the will of the people.

Abortion is not health care, as the abortion industry and President Obama, Nancy Pelosi and Harry Reid would like Americans to believe, and it should not be mandated under any health insurance plan, especially one that Americans will be forced to subsidize.

The proposed health care bill amounts to a “bailout” for the abortion industry, which is glutted with profits already, and will result in the largest expansion of abortion since Roe v. Wade. Since Roe v. Wade, 52 million American lives have been ended by abortion.

Tell Congress to vote no on any health care bill that does not include specific language to explicitly exclude abortion from any health care legislation.

And should your senator or representative glibly ignore your imperative, reserve an emphatic no for him or her at the next congressional election.

Patrick A. Burdick

Oneonta

Groups look out for owners, communities

Bob Rosen’s recent letter envisions landowner leaders sipping Mai Tais in the Caribbean with gas tycoons, Wall Street bankers, politicians aligned with the industry, and large land barons. Protected from financial inability by coalition leases, they chortle as they think of the vast wasteland they left behind.

I don’t know what Lex Luthor alternate universe Bob lives in, but here’s the real story. There are 35 coalitions with 800,000 acres pledged in eight counties of the Southern Tier. Leaders of these coalitions, with their steering committees, got off their duffs to educate and organize their friends and neighbors who were being sold generic leases by drilling companies. They then hired lawyers who created leases protective of individual rights and the community as a whole.

For instance, the Unatego association’s lease is 36 pages long. Even beyond state law, the lease provides penalties for environmental violations. The “protection from financial inability” that Bob refers to is $2 million in general liability insurance, enhanced by a $10 million umbrella policy, for each landowner. This insurance is purchased by the driller and is readily available. Why? Actuarial history indicates minimal risk.

Yes, Bob, coalition members hope to make money.

They will spend and/or bank it locally (although the Caribbean does sound tempting this time of year). The industry, directly and indirectly, will create goodpaying jobs. It will pay local, state and federal taxes. It will lead to greater energy independence. It can be the transitional fuel to what might be a hydrocarbon-free future.

The doomsday scenario the anti-drillers paint for New York is a hoax. With minimal risk and a little geological luck, New York just might be able to drill itself out of its hole.

Dave Parker

Worcester

Dick Downey

Otego

DOWNEY is with the Unatego Area Landowners Association. Parker is with the Worcester Area Landowners Gas Lease Coalition.