The Daily Star, Oneonta, NY - otsego county news, delaware county news, oneonta news, oneonta sports

December 12, 2009

Budget not pretty, but could be worse


No one wants to hear that his taxes are going up. No more welcome is news of local jobs being lost because of budgetary constraints. Yet we cannot find much fault with Otsego County’s 2010 budget, which was the result of much wrangling and numbercrunching by the county board and the county treasurer’s office.

Facing rising costs and decreased revenues, County Treasurer Myrna Thayne presented a tentative budget in November calling for an increase to the property-tax levy of more than 11 percent. The budget would also have cut nine jobs from the sheriff’s workforce.

By the time the county board approved the budget, it had evolved significantly from Thayne’s proposal. While the sheriff’s department kept its employees, as well as its boat patrol, other jobs were lost.

STOP-DWI Coordinator Karen Liddle spoke out against the board’s decision to eliminate her position, calling it unethical and possibly illegal. Her duties have been transferred to the sheriff’s department _ a move Liddle argued could set up a conflict of interest, since the department is among the beneficiaries of STOP-DWI funding.

While we have sympathy for Liddle’s desire to keep the job she loves, we feel the county has taken appropriate steps to guard against any conflict. Since proposed STOP DWI budgets go through the county board before being submitted to the state, there would be no way for the sheriff to “take all the money and put it into his program and no one else is going to see it,” as Liddle suggested.

At least one more county employee _ geographic information systems coordinator Marybeth Vargha _ will also be out of a job. Vargha has overseen the county’s mapping system for the last eight years. The fruits of her labors can be seen on the county’s website, where intricate, interactive maps show school districts, wetlands, tax parcels, historic districts, Empire Zones and more.

County officials have bemoaned the loss of Vargha, and we agree. The online maps _ which represent only a fraction of her work for the county _ are an amazing tool for the public to access. We hope the county is able to continue providing this valuable service without her expertise.

The budget includes other sacrifices that aren’t pleasant to face.

Efforts to restore funds for senior meals sites were stymied. Funds for arts organizations were cut, and money for additional 911 dispatchers wasn’t approved.

While we bemoan these losses, we know the county’s task was monumental, and the outcome could have been