This week’s “My turn”
column is by Oneonta Mayor
John S. Nader.
It is long past time
to review, revise and
rewrite our city charter.
The document is obsolete
and too often hinders
rather than facilitates
effective, representative
government.
As New York’s Department
of State notes,
“A good charter should
provide a clear distribution
of the powers of city
government and a clear
description of the duties
and powers of municipal
officials.” Our charter
does neither.
Therefore, consistent
with New York State
Home Rule Law, I intend
this year to establish a
charter review
commission.
The commission
should
review
the entire
charter
and prepare
a new
or significantly revised
version. Our charter diffuses
authority among numerous
entities without
sufficiently empowering
those who assume dayto-
day responsibility for
public administration
and policy.
Simply put, the
document’s lines of accountability
are unrealistic,
the duties of elected
officials are obscure; it
establishes a chief executive
position without
sufficiently empowering
the office.
A citizen can read the
city charter and find that
Oneonta’s form of government
defies description.
Although the city’s
form of government has
at times been called a
weak-mayor system, this
characterization is inaccurate.
It is far more accurate
to view the charter as the
by-product of the early
20th century, when many
localities empowered
boards and commissions
whose members were
certainly conscientious,
but plainly unelected. In
fact, the most significant
of those commissions no
longer even exist.
Unlike our federal
constitution, which provides
a clear separation
of powers, the city
charter seems as likely to
confuse as to clarify.
In one instance the
lines of authority overlap
so wildly that within two
paragraphs, the charter
actually requires
the supervisor of parks
and streets to report to
four separate entities:
a board, a commission,
the city engineer and the
mayor.
Another element of
the charter is nearly
comical. Among the few
explicit duties delegated
to individual Common
Council members is to
serve as “fence viewers”
who “shall possess all the
powers and authority in
respect to the division
of fences or walls within
their ward …”
In other instances, the
duties enumerated for
some of the appointed
boards and commission
are better defined and
detailed than those of the
elected Common Council
members. Sadly, the
process for adopting a
city budget is almost as
quaint and dated as the
fence viewers’ role.
Indeed, the formal
role of the mayor _ the
one city-wide elected
official _ in the budget
formulation process is
quite limited. More importantly,
the budget provisions
of the charter still
include a role for commissions
that have long
since been disbanded.
A city charter is
plainly not a topic that
prompts significant attention.
So why does it
matter? Our charter is
simply not adequate to
the needs of a modern,
progressive city. Officials
from other municipalities
are startled to learn
of the fragmentation that
can frustrate timely action
here.
A modern charter
should empower city officials,
particularly the
chief executive, to act
on behalf of their constituents.
The mayor is
designated as the chief
executive and charged
with “exerting a constant
supervision and control
over ... all city officers,”
but is provided neither
the time nor the means to
do so.
More importantly, the
vital roles of a modern
mayor in working with
other levels of government,
sustaining the
city’s tax base and infrastructure,
stewarding
its cultural and natural
resources, and establishing
and implementing a
vision and direction for
the city are crucial but
completely unrecognized.
The time for charter
review is now. Changes
both simple and substantial
are needed. City
officials attempted this
without success in both
the 1960s and 1970s.
In reviewing the minutes
from the commission
that worked in the
late 1970s, it is clear that
many of those elected
and appointed officials
who spoke before the
commission agreed that
the present structure is
more likely to restrain
prompt and timely action
in the public interest
than to facilitate such
action.
Now more than ever,
the current environment
should prompt us to
look to the future. Real
transformations are at
work. We see this daily
in government, in some
neighborhoods, and in
the rapidly changing economic
environment.
We are not immune
to these trends. In the
coming years, many cities
will find it increasingly
difficult to sustain
basic infrastructure and
services. Even an economic
recovery by itself
will not return us to a
comfortable place from
the past.
Charter revision is
no substitute for having
conscientious elected
officials who serve the
common good rather than
narrow, parochial interests.
Clearly the original
authors of the charter
knew this.
However, the organizational
structure of city
government needs to be
adjusted so that we can
better serve our citizens
and our posterity. Now
that we have celebrated
our centennial, let’s turn
our attention to making
the charter of the city
consistent with the need
for government to be responsive,
nimble and efficient.
It is long overdue.
To write for “My turn,”
contact Daily Star Publisher
Tanya Shalor at
tshalor@thedailystar.com
or 432-1000, ext. 214.
Columns
Related Photos
-
Nader
Discussion
Welcome to our story comments feature. We welcome your thoughts and your opinions, including the unpopular ones. We only ask that you keep your conversations clean, civil and on the topic of the story you are commenting on.
Coinciding with our websites redesign, we launched our new story comments feature through Disqus.
Disqus gives users the ability to log into our story comments feature so that they may be able to track their conversations, receive emails when their comments get a reply or to even have your comments update onto your Facebook or Twitter accounts.
For the time being, our story comments feature will continue to have the ability to post comments anonymously. We reserve the right to require registration in the future using your name and verified email address.
Not all comments are deemed printable. Some are disqualified at the newspaper’s discretion for a number of different reasons. Please follow our Online Rules of Conduct at all times.
RULES OF CONDUCT:
We reserve the right to remove comments that are unacceptable, to wit:
1. False and inacurate statements.
2. Personal attacks. Explicit name-calling.
3. Harassing, harmful, vulgar, obscene and defamatory language.
4. Threatening statements or statements that suggest violence.
5. Hate speech of any kind.
6. Intolerant comments on religion, race, age, gender, sexual preference or disabilities.
7. Accusations of criminal activity.
8. Content that is harmful to children and minors in any way.
9. References to any type of sexual activity and other private matters.
10. Random and inflammatory statements that are off topic.
11. Advertising of any kind.
12. Typing in all caps.
WE ENCOURAGE REASONABLE AND COURTEOUS COMMENTS THAT:
1. Create conversation on issues of interest and concern to fellow readers and local community members.
2. Express opinions and contrarian views.
3. Stimulate debate with respectful language.
4. Stay within the boundaries of these rules.
WE RESERVE THE RIGHT TO SUSPEND OR TERMINATE ACCESS FOR:
1. Violating any of these Online Rules of Conduct.
2. Deliberately disrupting discussions with repetitive messages, meaningless messages or spam.
3. Misrepresentation of identity or impersonating another user.
WE WELCOME:
1. Flagging violations of these rules that you observe to our attention.
MONITORING:
We monitor comments regularly Monday - Friday, 8 a.m. to 5 p.m. Approval of comments outside of this time (including weekends) will be sporadic.
My Turn: City charter needs revision
- Big Chuck D'Imperio
-
-
My pal Brucie, savior of Sidney's hospital
Ask any hospital administrators if they've ever heard of a closed hospital in New York state that has ever been re-opened. They will say, "Impossible." In a half century of going through records you can't find any.
Continued ... - Catching a whiff of 'Vermont Vapor'
- Selections from the virtual mailbag
- Recalling days of 'Doughnut King'
- Opera great's visit still a thrilling memory
-
My pal Brucie, savior of Sidney's hospital
- Cary Brunswick
-
-
We've become our own worst enemies
The past month has been marked by a seeming unprecedented number of man-made tragedies, as distinct from those caused by violent outbursts of the natural world, such as earthquakes, hurricanes and tsunamis.
Continued ... - Plenty of blame to go around for Bangladesh horror
- Obama is going against his word on Social Security
- Reflecting on a Florida trip
- Those magnificent spies in their flying machines
-
We've become our own worst enemies
- Chuck Pinkey
- Guest Column
-
-
Records seizure is an insult to free press
Distrust of government secrecy has been elevated to an exceptional level with the disclosure the Justice Department covertly examined two months of Associated Press phone records to determine who leaked details to the AP about a foiled terrorist plot.
Continued ... - The evangelical view of same-sex marriage
- Manor's fate will be Otsego board's legacy
- A closer look at our economy - Part II
- Use fracking to fill budget gaps
-
Records seizure is an insult to free press
- Lisa Miller
-
-
A view from above
Fire towers in the Catskill Mountains have always been destination points, built to capture some of the region’s best views. These sentinel stations served an important role for the earliest possible sightings of forest fires in the remote mountain ranges. But the fire towers and those who manned them fulfilled a multitude of other roles as well.
Continued ... - Being a parent is a constant learning process
- Healthy doesn't have to mean expensive
- A family era ends with close of Potter series
- Independent stores make up for loss of Borders
-
- Mark Simonson
-
-
Sunday movies in Oneonta finally shown in 1934
You know an issue is divisive when a vote to resolve it is quite close. In Oneonta during the early 1930s there were probably plenty of discussions or arguments at the family dinner table or sermons from the pulpits on Sunday mornings, regarding whether or should be able to see a movie in Oneonta on Sunday.
Continued ... - Politics, fitness and landmarks dominated local news in May 1968
- Local people sought income in many ways in 1933
- Local windstorm in 1983 caused tense moments
- Disaster, expansions put people to work in May 1913
-
- Rick Brockway
-
-
Kids have sparkle in their eyes
When I was in my teens, old Bill Naatz told me about a stream north of Lake George where a man had panned out enough gold to make his wife a wedding band. It was all rumors, but to his grandson and myself, it sounded like the makings of a great adventure.
- People make the outdoors even better
- Turkey season has ups and downs
- Spring air isn't always the freshest
- Adriondacks keep growing and growing
-
Kids have sparkle in their eyes
- Sam Pollak
-
-
Using time off in the worst way possible
"You don't mean it," I pleaded. "You simply can't mean it!"
Continued ... - Terror lives on, and there's no end in sight
- Remembering the glory of their times
- Column on guns led to a barrage of (mostly) jeers
- No one is coming to take your guns
-
Using time off in the worst way possible
- William Masters
-
-
Schreibman tops Chris Gibson on women's issues
As the time to vote draws near, we need to remember how money can run politics more than we can. Raising funds is a prominent (if not the dominant) task of getting elected. Raising issues is also crucial, but those efforts are subject to distortion and fear-mongering.
- Republicans feelentitled to allthey can garner An entitlement is a legal benefit available from the government to individuals who are within a defined category of recipients, such as needing insurance for unemployment or health services.
-
Romney focuses on self; Obama emphasizes unity
Mitt Romney criticizes President Obama for saying a person's success is rooted in his community, and is not all his alone. Romney belittles this with his belief in individual initiative. He is better at the put-down than the push-up.
-
Romney shows little regard for common man
The Republicans in Congress have voted over and over, 33 times, redundantly and uselessly, to rescind what they call Obamacare.
-
Scouts' gay ban creates problem where none exists
The Boy Scouts of America's "emphatic reaffirmation" of its vow to exclude any and all homosexuals from its hallowed ranks is ill-considered and pathetic, especially in view of its having reviewed the matter for two years.
-
Schreibman tops Chris Gibson on women's issues
