Although opponents of the "hydrofracking" method of drilling for natural gas have raised many concerns about potential for contamination of water and air, little has been written about what this would mean for human health.
Although it is to be hoped that "fracking fluid" would never enter ground water, there are already many examples of communities where this has happened.
What is in "fracking fluid," and why should we be afraid of it? This is not fully known, as the manufacturers have a "proprietary" right to non-disclosure. However, researchers have been able to recognize many of the chemicals used by analysis of spills and from the logs of hazardous materials required for interstate transport. (This information is available at www.endocrinedisruption.com/)
In the limited reports of the fracking fluid used in Pennsylvania, analysts have found at least 63 different compounds: Of these, about three-quarters have one or more toxic effects.
The residents of Dimock, Pa., whose wells have been contaminated, have complained of gastrointestinal, respiratory and neurological symptoms. These organ systems serve as an early-warning system, or "canary in the mine" for many toxins.
Many of chemicals listed are known neurotoxins. A neurotoxin poisons the activity of the brain and nervous system. Symptoms may vary widely from headache to confusion to numbness, tingling or pain in the extremities. These symptoms are non-specific and it is difficult for physician's to recognize a cause in many cases. These types of toxicity are likely to result in permanent and debilitating damage.
Most of the chemicals listed are irritants upon direct contact. Depending upon the intensity of exposure, that irritation to skin would range from a severe burn to a minor rash. In the eye and airway and gastrointestinal tract a similar spectrum of complaints could be noted. Most of these complaints (from an irritant) would likely be reversible if the exposure ceased, although some would not be. Some of the agents are "sensitizers". A sensitizer makes a person more susceptible to an allergic stimulus and could lead to chronic and irreversible conditions.
Roughly a third of the chemicals are known to cause cancer, affect reproductive health, cause birth defects, or are endocrine/hormone disruptors. These toxicities commonly have a long interval between exposure and disease (a latency period), and to date there is no known level of safe exposure. Additionally, exposures may have different effects at different stages of life (including intrauterine development), and may, through genetic alteration, be passed down to future generations. Although marginally treatable, these health issues are almost always irreversible. It might be many years before the families and their future generations in Dimock begin to experience these problems.
The industrial processes around hydrofracking also release heavy metals and noxious gases such as volatile organic compounds, nitrogen oxides, and ozone. These are most likely to injure the respiratory and neurological systems, again presenting with a wide array of symptoms.
In tracking the cause of a health problem related to an environmental exposure, there is rarely a "smoking gun", such as the oil soaked dead pelicans washing ashore in the Gulf of Mexico. There are many reasons why it is difficult to identify a cause and effect relationship between an environmental exposure and a health problem. First, unless the exposure is massive or acute, many environmentally provoked health problems occur after long and highly variable intervals, obscuring the cause. This is true of most carcinogens and endocrine disruptors. Secondly, some individuals will have more problems than others, depending on their underlying health problems. Thirdly, complaints are often non-specific. This means that the symptoms may be very common even in healthy individuals, for example headaches. In the case of chronic very low dose exposures, the cumulative damage over long periods may be entirely different from the symptom complex seen with an acute or massive exposure. In fact, the great majority of industrial and environmental toxins have never been tested for chronic, low dose exposures, and traditional toxicology literature is almost entirely based on animal models, except where inadvertent human exposure has occurred.
Given the overall lack of information available for these agents, the potential for widespread and multi-faceted exposures and our inability to monitor and track health risks, it is safe to say that the medical community is not prepared to effectively detect or manage the short or long term effects of contamination from the chemicals used in and generated by the hydrofracking process. Since we cannot be certain that such contamination will not occur, we should oppose this technology. We cannot allow our addiction to fossil fuels to blind us to the unpleasant truths about the potential dangers of hydrofracking.
Amy FreetH, M.D., Specializes in diabetes, metabolism, endocrinology and internal medicine. Antoinette Kuzminski, M.D., specializes in internal medicine. Both work with the Bassett Healthcare Network based in Cooperstown.
Columns
Local column: Little said about health effects of drilling
- Big Chuck D'Imperio
- Cary Brunswick
-
-
What books would you recommend for a young reader?
What then, would be on that short list of books you might pass along to young people to help them prepare for life, and how do you decide which titles to include and which to omit?
Continued ... - Some wisdom is best passed down through books
- Let pragmatism, not politics, determine birth control debate
- As Center Street Elementary goes, so goes Center City
- U.S. intervention in Syria's uprising would be a gamble
-
- Chuck Pinkey
- Guest Column
-
-
If we don’t develop a sustainable system, who will?
In Otsego County’s local elections last fall, a number of candidates — most of them on the independent Sustainable Otsego line — ran on an anti-fracking, pro-sustainability platform. They recognized that our current way of life — dependent on increasingly scarce, costly and polluting fossil fuels — cannot continue.
Continued ... - Time to get off the bus and on the computer
- Cuomo's Machiavellian maneuvers are a danger
- Home rule laws aren't a radical idea
- Sustainable shouldn't be a dirty word
-
If we don’t develop a sustainable system, who will?
- Lisa Miller
-
-
Being a parent is a constant learning process
I am sitting cross-legged on the floor in the dressing room, waiting for Allie's dance number to be called. The cave girl costume has been donned, the jazz shoes double-tied, the hair pulled back, the requisite dab of lipstick applied.
Continued ... - Healthy doesn't have to mean expensive
- A family era ends with close of Potter series
- Independent stores make up for loss of Borders
- Untethered from the cable box
-
Being a parent is a constant learning process
- Mark Simonson
-
-
A Main Street facelift for Oneonta in the 1920s
It has been just a little over 30 years, 1980 in fact, that Main Street in Oneonta went through a major transformation in appearance. Even now I'll hear mixed comments about the changes, which included antique style lamps, trees, planters and brick trim. Some liked the changes while others liked the wider street with the even-sized sidewalks.
Continued ... - Perfect attendance by Saturday’s Bread for 20 years in Oneonta
- Recalling the Hindenburg, John D. Rockefeller in May 1937
- Oneonta residents had diversions aplenty in the spring of 1952
- Damaschke essential to ensuring Oneonta baseball in 1927
-
A Main Street facelift for Oneonta in the 1920s
- Rick Brockway
-
-
It’s easy to get hooked on Thirteenth Lake
OUTDOORS COLUMN BY RICK BROCKWAY ... With Memorial Day almost upon us, I was reminded of a great fishing adventure many years ago on this weekend.
- Climbing is one thing, but skydiving?
- Rattlesnakes may be closer than you think, so pay attention
- Spring is here, so fishing should pick up soon
- Sneaky fox may be the next animal looking to horse around
-
It’s easy to get hooked on Thirteenth Lake
- Sam Pollak
-
-
I'm happy with our kids to a certain degree
It was several years ago, and I was in the kitchen, telling my eldest daughter and my then-teenaged son about the person who was taking over as publisher at The Daily Star.
Continued ... - I get by with a little help from my 'friends'
- It’s not easy for a politics junkie to get off the stuff
- The Encyclopaedia Britannica in print, unmourned by me
- Angelo Dundee was always a good man to have in your corner
-
- William Masters
-
-
Time for lawmakers who put needs of society first
Richard Lugar, after six terms as a Republican senator -- known for his middle of the road rationality and his foreign policy finesse -- has been ousted by a Tea Party extremist backed by outside right-wing funding.
-
War not worth gambling with lives of soldiers
Are you not tired of our war in Afghanistan? It had a point, once, after 9/11. Bush couldn't distinguish his myopic personal agendas from the nation's needs and let Osama escape, dropping the ball entirely, causing many deaths.
-
Titanic was a microcosm of U.S. economic disparity
Haunting reminders of the Titanic tragedy have wafted over us with the centenary of its sinking. The maiden voyage of an impressive, state of the art vessel, was a little like that of the Challenger space shuttle, at the cutting edge of developing technology. But the shuttle carried our pride in science and space exploration, not hundreds and hundreds of people.
-
William Masters: Nation stands divided between 'us' and 'them'
In February, Trayvon Martin was shot dead as "suspicious" by a volunteer neighborhood watch man. The case has aroused community reaction in Sanford, Fla., and is still echoing across the country.
-
A quarterback can't win the game alone
What is the relationship between democracy and wealth? Democracy is a political system, while wealth relates to economics. We have equal political rights, but we don't all have money. Extreme differences destroy the continuity of community solidarity.
-
Time for lawmakers who put needs of society first
