The Daily Star, Oneonta, NY - otsego county news, delaware county news, oneonta news, oneonta sports

Cary Brunswick

October 3, 2009

Obama has chance to keep peace with Iran

With Iran, it's starting to sound awfully like seven years ago, when Bush and Cheney were waving their swords at Iraq as their campaign of lies and deceit was under way leading up to the invasion.

It seems the only phrase we're not hearing is WMD for weapons of mass destruction.

Yet again, those of us who thought President Obama was the peace candidate can just shake our heads and wonder what happened and how we got fooled again.

So the United States and its allies seem to agree Iran has begun some secret nuclear activity that they fear is weapons-related. Iran admits it has a growing nuclear program, but insists it's related to energy production.

Israel, which Iran considers to be our 51st state, has subtly posed the possibility of a pre-emptive nuclear strike, so Iran tests some medium-range missiles as a show of potential response.

It's the stuff future wars are made of, and smells way too much like the months leading up to the Iraq war, which turned out to be a tragic mistake from which we've been unable to free ourselves long after no WMD were found.

The killing continues in Iraq despite or because of our invasion six and a half years ago. Obama has less than a year to keep his pledge that we'll be out of Iraq, with the chances of avoiding a civil war once we leave no better today than in 2003.

And now the top commander in Afghanistan says we need to send another 40,000 troops there, which would bring the total to more than 100,000. Obama already sent about 20,000 more earlier this year.

That would certainly fit into Obama's campaign statements that we should shift our focus to Afghanistan, where it should have been all along, rather than on Iraq. Today, however, is not 2003, and our years of lacking an Afghan focus have allowed our so-called enemies to regroup.

More American and NATO troops are dying in Afghanistan now than in 2001 when we first bombed and invaded.

In the wake of Afghanistan's fraudulent elections in August, even Obama's people are starting to question why we're fighting the Taliban anyway, when we really were after al-Qaida for planning all those attacks against us, such as 9/11.

Dealing with the 40,000-more-troops issue, Congress knows that people are about as fed up with Afghanistan as they are with Iraq, so some lawmakers are urging Obama to come up with some sort of timeline for withdrawing U.S. troops.

In one recent poll, more than half of respondents opposed sending more troops and more than third wanted us to get out now.

Of course, Defense Secretary Robert Gates, a Bush-Cheney holdover, insists that the Afghan war is vital to our national security. Yeah, just like Iraq was.

Against that backdrop, now we have Iran and Israel shaking missiles at each other, the U.S. and European allies pointing swords and sanctions at Iran, and Iran saying, OK, come and take a look; we have nothing to hide; the nukes are for juice.

Unfortunately, Iranian President Mahmoud Ahmadinejad is less trustworthy than our last president, so it's easy to be skeptical. Unlike in the propaganda whirlwind leading up the Iraq invasion, however, this time around even our spy agencies are saying there is no evidence of Iranian nuclear weapons production since 2003.

During the presidential campaign last year, Obama was criticized by some for saying he would be willing to talk to and even meet with adversaries to work out differences without having to resort to military options. Some thought it outrageous that he would be willing to communicate with a Bush axis-of-evil country such as Iran.

Actually, it wouldn't be outrageous at all, and it is exactly what is needed now, before all the chest-beating and play-acting leads to a breakdown in whatever civility remains and ultimately to military action.

Obama can't be blamed, perhaps, for not yet getting us out of Iraq and Afghanistan, but with Iran he has a chance to use his negotiating skills and follow through on other attributes that led so many people to vote for him, to bring about peaceful relations.

You know, too, that sometimes it's naive to be idealist and believe that some back-room, existential thinking and talking might help work things out among adversaries.

But I really think if we put all these major players out on some mountaintop on a clear night, so they all could just lie back and look out at the stars and universe beyond, and talk about what they are imagining, they just might realize that fighting and killing each other is not the answer.

It definitely could be more productive than sitting around big summit tables over bottled water.

___

Cary Brunswick, a former managing editor of The Daily Star, is a freelance writer and editor. He can be reached at brunswick@earthling.net.

Text Only
Cary Brunswick
  • Santorum, Obama both got it wrong on Honduras

    In one of the recent GOP presidential debates in Florida, candidate Rick Santorum ripped President Barack Obama for his policies on Latin and Central America in general and Honduras in particular.

    1 Photo
  • Pumpkin seeds and the problem of China imports

    I was shopping at a local supermarket recently and bought some organic pumpkin seeds. Ordinarily, I check over food-product labels but didn't think about it this time, knowing there are so many pumpkins grown not only in upstate New York but also in the nation. The shock I experienced when I got home points to what I believe is the biggest facet of the economic and jobs crisis facing our country.

    1 Photo
  • Unrest, energy, economy were big news in 2011

    Perhaps you've seen The Associated Press list of the Top 10 stories of the past year, based on a polling of about 250 editors and news directors from across the country. It's difficult to argue with the selections, but I would combine some of them and certainly rank them differently.

    1 Photo
  • Trading freedom for security isn't American

    Back in the late 1960s, after the election of President Richard Nixon, one of the common phrases of protesters was that the United States might be the first nation to go fascist by democratic vote.

    1 Photo
  • Occupy Wall Street protests changed the conversation

    During the past week, numerous Occupy Wall Street encampments have been shut down in cities across the country, with police making arrests and sometimes clashing with campers and their supporters.

  • Saturday, October 29, 2011
  • Nov. 8 looms large for friends, foes of hydrofracking

    The future of fracking _ and perhaps our region’s clean water _ will likely be decided in the courts, but perhaps also in the voting booth on Election Day, Nov. 8.

  • Saturday, October 8, 2011
  • Fear and frustration fuel the rise of Wall Street protests

    What is it those protesters want, anyway? That's what many people are asking as the demonstrations using Wall Street as their evil icon continue to grow and spread, with rallies this weekend expected to be the largest yet.

  • Sunday, September 18, 2011
  • Airport funds could be better spent elsewhere

    Don't get me wrong, I have nothing against private planes and flying, but something's out of whack when the Oneonta airport gets funding of nearly half a million federal dollars while the city's streets are crumbling beneath local motorists.

  • Saturday, August 27, 2011
  • Communication is key to keeping neighbors friendly

    When I was in college, I lived in a two-bedroom apartment one year with three other students in a residential neighborhood, long before most communities had zoning laws.

  • Monday, August 8, 2011
  • Don't let frack proposal go unchallenged

    What a frackin' mess.

  • Saturday, July 16, 2011
  • Memories will stay on ink, paper

    Join me now in the disorder of boxes and paper folders wrenched open after years of abandonment, saturating the air with dust, the floor covered with yellowed paper, some covered with ink, others type. NetSummary

  • Saturday, June 25, 2011
  • Grads must discover who they are

    High school graduates this weekend are hearing speeches from administrators and their top academic classmates about how important their parents, teachers and friends were as they enter the new paths they've chosen from what life has to offer.

    1 Photo
  • Saturday, June 4, 2011
  • Some war vets' experiences too harrowing to retell

    The Little League season was winding down and it hadn't been a great year for my American Legion team. After practice, my father, the coach, stopped by the Legion for a glass of beer and said I could go in with him. It was June 6.

    1 Photo
  • Saturday, May 14, 2011
  • Peace, not death, would be cause for celebration

    "I will mourn the loss of thousands of precious lives, but I will not rejoice in the death of one, not even an enemy." _Jessica Dovey, English teacher, after hearing of Osama bin Laden's death

    1 Photo
  • Saturday, April 23, 2011
  • Nuclear risks as scary now as 32 years ago

    A little more than 32 years ago, a small group of homesteaders huddled in a cabin on a Fingers Lakes hilltop on the day a nuclear emergency was declared at the Three Mile Island nuclear-power plant near Harrisburg, Pa.

    1 Photo
  • Saturday, April 2, 2011
  • 'Obama Doctrine' is same tune, different words

    I've been witness to the United States intervening both militarily and covertly in the uprisings and civil wars of other countries for half a century, and what's now being termed the Obama Doctrine in Libya doesn't look much different from many of our other forays.

    1 Photo
  • Saturday, March 12, 2011
  • Let's not blame workers for the gains of unions

    I was a member of a labor union years ago when I worked for a railroad. I was forced to join because it was a closed shop. For $7 a week for dues taken out of my check, I made a dollar more than minimum wage and the bosses couldn't make me get a haircut.

    1 Photo
  • Saturday, February 19, 2011
  • Lack of jobs, opportunity drive revolts

    Just as in the United States when economic struggles can cause incumbent presidents to be ousted in their re-election bids, it's the economy that is fueling the unrest and revolts in northern Africa and the Middle East.

    1 Photo
  • Saturday, January 29, 2011
  • Our vision for future demands a response now

    On Tuesday night, President Obama in his State of the Union address offered his vision for our future, but what will the world really be like in 2040? Peaceful, poison, hungry or thriving?

    1 Photo
  • Saturday, January 8, 2011
  • Smartphone holdout resists pace of technology change

    My television is square, and my phone is stupid.  But I might not be any brighter than my phone, because I'm not one of the 100 million Americans who bought smartphones last year. (Yes, believe it or not, "smartphone" is now considered a word.) And apparently I'm not any cooler than my TV, because I have to look up what abbreviations such as LCD and LED mean when I see them in television ads. Somehow, I was able to figure out on my own what HD stood for.

    1 Photo

Additional Content
Join the Debate
Helium
Additional Resources
CNHI News Service
Poll

Do you think women should serve in front-line combat situations?

Yes
No
     View Results